Inside the 2012 CASS Climate Report

If you want to know what the 2012 CASS report really said, rather than what the headlines said about it, this is the place to start. The document runs to 98 pages, and most of it is slow, unglamorous work: taking one university course apart, claim by claim, and checking each one against the published science. We read it so you can get the shape of it in a few minutes. The original is linked at the end if you want the whole thing.

The report’s own summary did not hedge. It called the course “heavily biased against the scientific consensus” and laid out 142 specific claims to back that up.

Late-night desk with an open annotated textbook, glasses, coffee mug, and laptop under lamplight.

The Audit Briefly

First, the basic facts, so you know what kind of document this is.

ItemDetail
Published28 February 2012
Length98 pages
CourseERTH 2402, Climate Change: An Earth Sciences Perspective, Carleton University
AudienceSecond-year students, mostly non-science majors
Material reviewed12 recorded lectures, around 27 hours
Claims examined142, each checked against the literature
AuthorsFour volunteers, none with industry funding

How the Audit Worked

The method was plain, which is part of why it held up. Four volunteers watched the full set of recorded lectures from the 2010 to 2011 run of the course, wrote down statements that looked out of step with the science, and then went to the peer-reviewed literature to check them. They ended up with 142 claims, quoted directly from the instructor and his guest speakers, and wrote a referenced response to each one.

They also flagged how the course taught, not just what it taught. One running exercise asked students to find a mainstream climate statement in the news and knock it down using arguments the instructor handed them. The authors saw that as training students to repeat talking points, not to weigh evidence. The course also leaned on books and films rather than primary research, which left students with no way to trace a claim back to its source.

The Three Layers of the Argument

The report described the course as moving through three fallback positions, a pattern it tied to organised climate denial more broadly.

  1. Warming is not really happening. Doubt is cast on the temperature record, the weather stations, and even the idea of a global average.
  2. If it is happening, humans are not the cause. The blame shifts to the sun, cosmic rays, clouds, or natural cycles.
  3. If humans are a cause, it is not dangerous and might be good. This is where the slogan “carbon dioxide is plant food” does its work.

The Network Behind the Course

The part that drew the most attention was not any single claim. It was the company the course kept. The instructor and the guest speakers turned out to share a small set of advocacy groups and, in several cases, ties to a US think tank known for disputing climate science. The report set it out as a table.

NameRole in the courseListed ties (per the report)
Tom HarrisInstructorICSC, NRSP, Heartland Institute
Tim PattersonEarlier instructorFriends of Science, NRSP, ICSC, Heartland
Bob CarterShown on video in classNRSP, ICSC, Heartland
Ian ClarkGuest lecturerNRSP, ICSC
Tad MurtyGuest lecturerNRSP, ICSC

On the money, the report stayed specific and we will stay careful: these are the report’s figures, not numbers we checked ourselves. It noted that the International Climate Science Coalition had taken $45,000 from the Heartland Institute, that Heartland had budgeted six figures to develop school material casting climate science as uncertain, and that one of the speakers shown in class was on a monthly Heartland payment.

What the Report Concluded, and What It Asked For

The authors were careful not to call for anyone to be silenced. Their conclusions ran along a narrower line.

  • A course taught to non-scientists, with little primary literature and only one side of the argument, is not the same as promoting debate.
  • Where students know the least, accuracy and balance matter the most.
  • Academic freedom protects the instructor, and the report says so plainly, but it does not exempt course content from scrutiny.
  • If the course were to run again, the report offered its 142 responses as a starting point for fixing the material.
Desk with an open legal file, fountain pens, a numbered case binder, and a scales of justice figurine.

How they got the lectures

The report anticipated the charge of bad faith and answered it. The lead author, a Carleton staff member, asked the university’s video service for access and was given it. No subterfuge, and the authors printed the email exchange to prove it.

The other half of this story

This page covers what the report says. For how the team built the investigation and how it played out in the press, see the companion piece, how a volunteer team took on the course.

SOURCES AND FURTHER READING

  • Climate Change Denial in the Classroom, the original CASS report (PDF via the Internet Archive). The primary source for everything above.
  • Inside Climate News and DeSmog, for independent reporting on the instructor’s think-tank ties.
  • Centre for Inquiry Canada. centreforinquiry.ca

Disclaimer: This is an independent informational article about a publicly released report. It is not affiliated with the Committee for the Advancement of Scientific Skepticism (CASS) or the Centre for Inquiry Canada. Funding figures are drawn from the report itself and attributed as such. The original report and the news coverage are linked so readers can check the sources.