Is It Science? How to Check a Claim Before You Believe It

There is a meme that does the rounds every flu season. On one side, a scientist at a lab bench, labelled “vaccine research.” On the other, someone scrolling their phone on the toilet, labelled “anti-vax research.” It gets a laugh, and we get why. But it also does something quietly that we want to argue against. It treats the word “skeptic” as an insult, and it assumes that anyone who doubts must be lazy, careless, or not very bright.

We think that is both unfair and, more practically, a bad way to change anyone’s mind. So, this is our attempt to do the opposite. Not to mock people who get fooled, but to lay out the questions we actually ask ourselves before we trust a claim, and to be honest about where those questions get hard.

When someone says “I’m just being skeptical,” one question sorts it out: are you asking what the evidence shows, or defending an answer you settled on first?

Desk with an open handwritten notebook, glasses, a smartphone, highlighter, and crumpled paper drafts.

The Word “Skeptic” Does Two Opposite Jobs

Most of the confusion online comes from one slippery word doing two contradictory things.

The first meaning is the one we care about. Scientific skepticism is a method. You take a claim, especially a surprising one, and you ask what evidence supports it, whether that evidence holds up, and whether it could in principle be shown to be wrong. This is the tradition that the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal started in the United States in 1976, the one Carl Sagan summed up in a line we still reach for: extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. A scientific skeptic is not someone who says no to everything. It is someone who wants to be shown.

The second meaning is almost the reverse, and it borrows the good word as a disguise. People who reject a well-established finding, whether that is the link between HIV and AIDS or the human role in climate change, often call themselves “skeptics” too. What they are doing is not open inquiry. It is starting from a conclusion they already hold and keeping only the evidence that flatters it. That goes by a different name: denial, or pseudoskepticism.

The Questions We Ask

None of what follows is special knowledge. It is a short list of questions, and most of the work is just remembering to ask them.

  1. Where did this come from? A study, a press release, a guy on a podcast, a friend of a friend. The claim and its source travel together, and a confident sentence with no traceable origin is a small red flag on its own.
  2. What would prove it wrong? Real findings can fail. If a claim is built so that no possible result could ever count against it, it has stopped being science and started being a belief.
  3. Has anyone else found the same thing? One result is a starting point, not a finding. We trust things more when separate people, with separate methods and motives, keep landing in the same place.
  4. What does the wider field say, and why? Consensus is not proof. But a strong agreement among the people closest to the evidence is a reasonable place to start, and the burden sits with whoever wants to overturn it.
  5. Who benefits? Follow the money and the motive, on every side. It cuts against industry-funded doubt, and against anyone selling a miracle cure. A conflict of interest does not make someone wrong, but it tells you where to look harder.
  6. Is the size of the claim matched by the evidence? “This tea is pleasant” needs almost nothing. “This tea cures cancer” needs a mountain. Most bad claims fail right here, on that gap.

Worked Example: the Wi-Fi Health Scare

Theory is easy, so here is the checklist run on a claim that keeps coming back: that the Wi-Fi in schools and homes is quietly making people ill.

The questionWhat we find for Wi-Fi
Where did it come from?Anecdotes and a few fringe voices, not studies
What would prove it wrong?Blind tests where people cannot feel the signal
Has anyone else found it?Large reviews find no effect at everyday levels
What does the field say?Health Canada and the WHO: no demonstrated risk
Who benefits?Sellers of shielding gear and EMF consultants
Is the claim sized to the evidence?Big harm claimed, very thin support behind it

Run it through all six and the claim comes apart at almost every step. Not because the people worried about Wi-Fi are foolish, the symptoms they feel are real, but because the cause does not survive the questions.

Why This Matters in Canada Right Now

This is not an abstract exercise. According to the 2026 Health and Media Tracking Survey, run by the Canadian Medical Association with Abacus Data, most people in Canada now look online for health advice, and that brings real risks.

What the 2026 survey foundFigure
Look online for health adviceAbout 9 in 10
More likely harmed after following AI health adviceAround 5x
Now skeptical of what they find onlineAbout 2 in 3

That last figure is the good news, and we want to sit on it for a second. Skepticism in the healthy sense is becoming the default, which is exactly the muscle this guide is trying to build. There is a structural catch, though: most platforms Canadians use are American and increasingly shaped by American politics. As Abacus Data’s David Coletto put it this year, “there is no border for lies.” A wave of health misinformation does not stop at the line on the map.

The Part Most Guides Skip: Not Every Doubter Is a Crank

Here is where we want to be careful, because the easy version of this article would end with “trust the experts” and a pat on the head. The honest version is messier.

People hesitate for reasons, and the reasons are not all stupid. A parent who watched their child react badly soon after a shot is not irrational to get nervous, even if the timing was coincidence. Someone from a community that medicine has genuinely mistreated is not paranoid for keeping their guard up. The evidence backs this up in an uncomfortable way: more education does not reliably make people less doubtful of science. So, the picture where skeptics simply failed chemistry class does not hold.

That changes how the conversation should go. Ridicule feels good and almost never works. Listening, and taking the specific worry seriously, has a much better track record. This is also why we keep our own side honest. A skeptic who has decided in advance that every alternative claim is nonsense has quietly slipped into the other kind of skepticism, the closed kind. The method only works if we are willing to be shown wrong too.

Two women talking in a cozy sitting room, seated in armchairs with tea and a plant nearby.

A Short Checklist to Keep Somewhere

The next time a claim lands in front of you, before you share it or act on it, run it past these.

  • Can I trace where this came from?
  • What evidence is offered, and could it have come out the other way?
  • Has anyone independent found the same thing?
  • What do the people closest to the question say, and is this claim overturning them?
  • Who gains if I believe this?
  • Is the evidence as big as the promise?
  • If it is about my health, have I asked a professional I can actually talk to?

None of this needs a science degree. It mostly needs slowing down for thirty seconds, which is harder than it sounds and worth more than it looks.

See the method in action

These same questions drive our case studies. Read how a science team audited a climate course, or what is really inside a homeopathy pill.

SOURCES AND FURTHER READING

  • “Scientific skepticism,” Wikipedia, for the history of the movement and the difference from pseudoskepticism.
  • Gabriele Contessa, in The Conversation (Creative Commons), on why dismissing doubters tends to backfire.
  • Canadian Medical Association and Abacus Data, 2026 Health and Media Tracking Survey.
  • Centre for Inquiry Canada, the “Is It Science?” campaign and the Critical Links newsletter.

Disclaimer: This is an independent informational article. It is not affiliated with CASS, the Centre for Inquiry Canada, or any organization named here, and it is not medical advice. If you have a health question, talk to a qualified professional who can look at your situation directly.